Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

US doesn't have a large demand for EVs so I doubt we'll see BYD in the US. They are building a factory in Mexico that is capable of 300,000 vehicles per year.


Not sure where you get that info from.

Demand is also relative to price and US EVs are very expensive.


"“We’re not planning to come to the US,” Stella Li, executive vice president of BYD and CEO of BYD Americas, told Yahoo Finance Live (video above). “It’s an interesting market, but it is very complicated,” she added, citing growing political pushback on Chinese companies and the slowing rate of growth for EV adoption."

From the largest maker of BEVs.


Fully-electric vehicles (BEVs) were 8.1% of all U.S. light vehicle sales in 2024. EV sales were up 15% year-over-year.

The CEO is worried about how hostile the U.S. market might be for Chinese companies, not about low demand.


China hit 50% of all new cars sold last summer. Mexico 8.2% of their cars were EVs last year and had 70% growth. US doesn't have an EV market, once the EV credits get pulled, bottom is going to fall out.


In 2024, battery electric vehicles (BEVs) made up 25% of new car sales in China (to compare apples to apples.)

That's a lot more than the US, but that's not the point. 8% is plenty large enough to be sizable market.

EV credits going away will dampen that, but that will also be partly or even fully offset just by how fast that segment is growing.


“BYD doesn’t want to sell in the US” (I presume due to strong anti-China sentiment which would harm an industry that is closely regulated by the government) is very different from “the US doesn’t have a large market for EVs” especially when the EVs BYD makes are low cost. And with Musk close with the government, BYD would be unlikely to be treated well any time soon. It makes sense that the CEO says “it is very complicated” but that is not the same as “the market is small”.


That doesn't say that demand is low, but that adoption is slowing, which could reflect many factors, including high prices.


Are they high? Average price paid in 2024 for a new car was $50k. There are tons of EVs under that price from Tesla model 3/y, For Mach E,Hyundai Ionic, a bunch of KIA models, VW ID4 etc.


Good job! You continue to fail to subtantiate your original claim (low US EV demand) very well!

A+ goalpost moving!


The auto industry in general appears to be slowing world wide


In terms of percentage of sales, the US is one of the smaller markets: https://ourworldindata.org/electric-car-sales (see the breakdown under “ Share of new cars sold that are battery-electric and plug-in hybrid, 2010 to 2023”, particularly the battery-electric section)

Now, the US is a big market, but even so, particularly with the US’s tariff barriers and unique consumer preferences (the average car in the US is a lot _bigger_ than elsewhere, and cars made for other markets do not sell well; for instance see the leaf), you can see why car makers would prefer to focus on the EU and China.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: