Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Did people buy less food after grocery stores raised prices? I doubt it. If you have something people require then you can increase prices a ton as long as you ensure everyone else also does it.

The reason this doesn't happen for groceries is that starting a grocery store is very easy, if everyone increases grocery prices a competitor with lower prices will appear extremely quickly. But for services that are harder to setup you can't do that, replacing a pharma or a chip company isn't something anyone can do even if they had lots of money.

And the reason we don't want a monopoly to set these prices is that it blocks progress. Imagine if you had to pay the maximum you'd be willing to pay for food instead of the cost it takes to produce? You'd be forced to spend most of your salary on food or ration it, that isn't a society you want to live in.



>Did people buy less food after grocery stores raised prices? I doubt it.

Yes they did. So your premise needs checked. Read any news about what happens to food sales as inflation outpaces income and it's abundantly clear stores cannot simply raise prices without losing sales. There's such easy literature to find you don't need to "doubt it" when you can simply check it. For example [1]

Some consumers purchase at the limit of what they can spend - there's no elasticity for them.

[1] https://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/full/10.2105/AJPH.2008...


> The reason this doesn't happen for groceries is that starting a grocery store is very easy, if everyone increases grocery prices a competitor with lower prices will appear extremely quickly.

But a) it is not clear that this is, in fact, true at this point in time, and b) even if it is, "extremely quickly" is still going to be on the order of a year or two.

The reason I say (a) is because the existing grocery store chains are very large, and very willing to lower prices locally to prevent a competitor from getting an edge on them. They also have significant economies of scale that allow them to drop prices lower than a new local upstart could and still make at least some profit.

In short, the barriers to entry are high enough that a few months of raised prices aren't enough to cause a competitor to appear out of nowhere, and any would-be competitor would need to either have massive resiliency to outlast the incumbents undercutting them (again, locally, such that it wouldn't make a blip in the overall inflation numbers), or somehow start up enough locations all at once that such an undercutting attack would be less feasible and much more visible.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: