Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Consciousness is the aggregate of emotional, sensory, and thought formations. With these forming a thread into a narrative through memory, we forge identities. All of this happens in the substrate that is consciousness.

If it is unclear why consciousness is not a social construct, you can experiment with isolation and introspection. Retreats, meditation, psychedelics, anything that involves observing the movements of your mind without getting tangled up into words and semantics.



> Consciousness is the aggregate of emotional, sensory, and thought formations...

That's one theory among many. Are these identities static or dynamic in nature?

> If it is unclear why consciousness is not a social construct, you can experiment with isolation and introspection. Retreats, meditation, psychedelics, anything that involves observing the movements of your mind without getting tangled up into words and semantics.

I don't find this compelling because it's really difficult to find a person who wasn't born to another person and lived amongst other people in order to run this experiment.

"Observing" myself thinking of a movie while I meditate seems circular and I don't think you can be an observer and be the observed at the same time.


It's as much a theory as saying that a body is formed of limbs, torso, head, etc. I have a body, I inhabit it and can observe it directly.

You're trying to word your way out of words.

It's like you're asking me what's atop a mountain and you keep making conjectures and assumptions about what is or isn't up there. The answer is to just go climb it instead of taking your assumptions for reality.

> I don't think you can be an observer and be the observed at the same time.

I can, because I practice it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: