I still think it's very poor design that the toggle is:
1 - Completely unlabeled, nor is the icon indicative/clear.
2 - Not sticky. It will turn itself back on, even though this is neither implied nor stated in the UI.
3 - The only way to actually turn it off is to dig into your search settings - what percentage of your users actually know that exists, much less think about looking there?
A UX lesson I just know: It is better to have options than unchangeable defaults.
Another UX lesson: do one thing and do it well. Apparently Google forgot that. I still think it is a great one. And yes, I know it pertains to the function software plays and web empires are a different beast, but I find the poetic irony of the down the rabbit hole fiasco being related to a *nix quib delicious.
I think as a professional it's incredibly useful to have little rules like this that provide a structure out of which to make quick judgements and decisions.
But don't become complacent and let these transform into actual beliefs. There is no quicker way to kill your creativity.