Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Take a step back and look at what you're doing: lamely attempting to justify and carry the water for Bitcoin's horrible energy waste and pollution

I think I'm not doing that. I'm just part of a conversation and my goal is not to make excuses for Bitcoin. Broadening the view and mentioning other facts doesn't mean that I make excuses for something else. I just don't want to argue pointlessly about this. I'm already in the "ban bitcoin" camp, so anything you try to say to convince me is also time wasted :)

I would advise, do more conversation and less argumentation on the forums



Then why do you think factories are as useless as bitcoin, if you think bitcoin should be banned, and why are you using whataboutism as an argument? Do you also want to ban heavy industry?

You're the one who is throwing whataboutism arguments around. So don't say you don't want to have an argument, after you started with an invalid whataboutism argument and an inconsistent position, in defense of another invalid argument that bitcoin is "a way of exporting abundant renewable electricity from isolated areas".

In case you haven't been paying attention for the past few years, of if you're only pretending to be incredulous, your argument and the argument you're defending are regularly made by bitcoin shills, and always shot down by the facts because they make no sense.

If you'd watch Line Goes Up or read any other comprehensive analysis critical of cryptocurrencies, you'd already know quit well how terribly bad and insincere your whataboutsim argument and the "exporting abundant renewable electricity" arguments you're defending are, and how thoroughly they have already been debunked, and how tired the HN community is of hearing them mindlessly parroted again and again.

You're not the first person to think of using whataboutism to justify bitcoin.


I think two different industries can be corrupt and environmentally damaging at the same time. It's not about picking sides. Maybe use common viewpoint to attack both problems.

You're just very rude in your first reply. That's one thing.

The second thing is that I don't care to argue so much about bitcoin, so I just want to not be in your path, you seem to really be angry about this. That's fine, but I don't want to be in the way. Let me leave thanks.


Heavy industry factories make such toxic waste comparing them to bitcoin is like comparing water to oil. The toxic waste created making credit cards or printing money is very toxic and not something you want to live beside.

Bitcoin uses electric power. So does electric cars, your iphone, lights that businesses leave on overnight. If you are against bitcoin because it uses power.. you really need to lobby for a law that would ban businesses polluting the night sky with lights that aren't needed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: