Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Presumably GC wants to know why you hate Discord so much. You've spent a lot of words saying you don't like it, but haven't actually enumerated why.


Ah. That, I can do.

Why I Hate Discord (A Manifesto) [Without Sources] Discord is aggressively proprietary.

People ought to own their data, but Discord's architecture ensures everything gets hoovered into the mother-ship. At first, this was for nothing more than to facilitate their client-server communications model; recently, all of the hoovered data gets submitted to their AI moderation platform. (searched for sources on this but it was very hard to find anything. I remember talk about this ~c. Nov 2020, might be wrong)

I should be able to modify an interface to my tastes. Modifying Discord is explicitly against their ToS, including their interface; attempting to do so will lead to a ban. Don't like their painted whore? Prefer to chat from your bespoke terminal? GTFO, Hammer & Chisel knows what's best for We Peons.

Addenda: I find Hammer & Chisel developers and Discord admins to be disgusting. This is hearsay & personal opinion from my time hanging around the developer chats, but they all came across as nasty people. I, personally, believe many of the news reports surrounding the grooming controversies; searching "Discord admin controversy," "Discord allthefoxes controversy," "Discord cub policy," &c. turn up some relevant articles. Most of these articles are from low-quality reporting shops, but I buy in to the narrative.


At any point Discord can decide they don't like your community and delete the entire thing without notice or archive.


Which as we recently saw with Freenode can also happen with IRC.

Except IRC doesn't even save your community's history in the first place.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: