Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How do people respond to imperfect Finnish?

In the US I (as a non-native speaker) was very pleasantly surprised that accents do not matter and mistakes that do not kill the meaning are universally tolerated. People would still gladly chat with you over beer, etc.

But that is not the case in some other countries: optional conversations suffer a lot if you, say miss a few conjugations.

Where do Finns stand on this?



They immediately reply in English and have little tolerance for someone speaking their language with even a vague accent.

Have seen it many times.


As a Finn, I'd interprete this as trying to be helpful, and less about not tolerating accent. "Oh, they're struggling with Finnish, it's easier for all of us if I switch to English." In my opinion, this is one of the top reasons for difficulties in learning Finnish - it's difficult to get the Finns talk Finnish with you. One has to insist.


Interesting. Is this professional conversations or in stores / restaurants / on the streets? I thought English is not spoken by many folks over there, at least outside the IT/tech scene.


If you pick an average person under 40 they will have near-perfect English. Partly due to media, partly due to the internet.

English seems common in the groups of immigrants you come across too. I know people who've moved from France, etc, and there are lots of immigrants from various countries - many of whom speak their own language, and English as the second. Some go on to learn Finnish to a greater or lesser extent.

I've ordered food in restaurants, cider/whisky in pubs, etc, and had the server just reply back in English.

Me: "saisinko omena cidre?" Them: "Do you want ice?"

On the one hand it is helpful at times, but on the other hand it is deeply frustrating. 90% of the staff at the local newsagents has pulled me aside on a quiet morning and asked "Do you prefer English or Finnish?" I say "Finnish", but to be honest the conversations I have with the shop-staff are mostly them reading the total, and asking "would you like a receipt/bag/anything else?" so it doesn't help me in any real sense, but it's nice they offer/ask.


I think if you tell people you want to practice your Finnish, and you're not in a busy restaurant / grocery store, they'll entertain you. Younger Finns just have stopped assuming that people would bother learning Finnish.


My experience at the store/ when ordering drinks has been that I'd get the replies more often than not in Finnish and had to switch to English myself when it was something that I didn't understand. Key is to get the pronunciation right - which is far easier as a German.

And yes, younger people know English well and will usually switch to English if you're struggling - unless they think that their English is too bad (which it usually isn't).

Alcohol is very expensive though!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: