Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is there any proof or details of how they did this? 350,000,000 is a lot of trees to source, distribute and plant in one day.


Planting a tree is as easy as planting a tiny seed in the ground. What all these headlines omit is that the majority of things planted won't survive. My back yard has a few thousand tree seedlings growing in it naturally.

When we hear of tree planting we picture a mayor or rich person planting a four year old tree in a park. The reality is that trees grow from seed.

In the case of commercial forestry all the trees planted won't make it.

A better vision of tree planting is Johnny Appleseed.

Edits. The Twitter from the Ethiopian minister says tree seedlings.


> When we hear of tree planting we picture a mayor or rich person planting a four year old tree in a park. The reality is that trees grow from seed.

Yeah but trees are hardline r-strategists and produce millions of disposable seeds with a very low survival rate. Planting a seed is in no way equivalent to planting a germinated, sprouted, and developed seedling.


Planting seeds is not "planting trees", thanks for the mention of seedlings -- that changes the complexion of the effort considerably.

Personally I'd expect a sapling to be the minimum developmental stage to qualify as "planting trees".


They only planted them in one day. I bet the distribution took a while...


The article gives no details but I'd look to see how many things are planted from seed in a nursery each day to at least get an indication of the number of things which can be "planted" in a given day.

Many trees could be said to have been planted by someone scattering apple seeds out of their pockets.


The article says something about 40 trees planted by each citizen... so I'm guessing this 350 M batch was distributed equally to everyone they could reach.


It does seem quite a bit, furiouspete talked about jobbing as a student in reforestation in Canada (his shrooms video) and apparently if you are quick you go through 4k a day per person a 12h shift.

https://youtu.be/tzHw86XmNgc?t=440


Finland we specialized tool which you can get easily 200 trees planted in an hour. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLtspCQPeqY


Even 200 seeds per hour would require ~145,000 participants to plant all 350M seeds in a 12 hr time frame. I’m literally just imagining a few guys with a leaf blower and a bag of seeds for how they got 350M in 12 hours haha.


They closed schools for this. There were a lot of people involved.


Not the worst way to teach kids a bit about how to nurture their environment. The absolute worst case here is a bunch of kids learning stuff and applying it later in their life. The best case is that and some meaningful percentage of these trees actually survives and helps restore a bit of land. Sounds like an interesting example to follow elsewhere. There's no shortage of recently arified land across the world.

I think there are a lot of countries finding out that they are not passive participants in the curve balls nature is throwing them and that they can influence what happens with simple, low tech solutions like planting trees and taking care of them and maybe a few simple changes in behavior like keeping sheep and cattle away from volatile areas.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: